Posted on 5 Comments

DC vs Marvel: Darkseid or Thanos, Who Is The Better Villain? (And First Appearance)

Darkseid vs Thanos in 'DC Versus Marvel.'
 

DC VS MARVEL


DEATH BATTLE!

IN SUPERVILLAINS

THE TOP A-LIST VILLAINS AT DC AND MARVEL

Darkseid vs Thanos in 'DC Versus Marvel.'

Last month, we ranked the formidabilities in a potential Darkseid vs Thanos battle. And we looked at the characters in continuity at their highest powers: Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet and Darkseid with the Anti-Life Equation.

Now, this month, we look at who between both A-list villains is the better villain.

To this end, we have come up with a villainy score that compares both characters in eight categories: Sales, Origin Story, Character Evolution, Cast, Quality Opponents, Villainy, Power, Popularity. Before we compare our villains let’s list some rules.

  1. The Villainy Score is rated out of 8 points.
  2. For Thanos, we list only the Earth-616 continuity and for Darkseid Post-Crisis, Post-Flashpoint and Rebirth.
  3. Since we are comparing Sales and Popularity, we include the villains’ performance in other media and their Google Search Results.
  4. For Power, we list their highest achievements across Earth-616, Post-Crisis, Post-Flashpoint and Rebirth continuities.

So, let’s compare Darkseid and Thanos in the villainy department.

BECOME A FREE MEMBER TO VIEW THE POWER LEVEL WIKI

VILLAINY SCORES

Darkseid.

VILLAINY SCORE: 4

SALES

For sales, Darkseid lags behind Thanos. In the comic medium, it appears the God of Evil is selling top dollar. In 2009, Final Crisis ranked 14 on the Top Comics of the year with an estimated 127,000 units sold.

Later, in 2020, the Justice League Dark: Apokolips War animated film made $5,474,989 in Total Estimated Domestic Video Sales. In the movie department, the success of Zack Snyder’s Justice League is not sufficient to overcome the Disney juggernaut.

Thanos.

VILLAINY SCORE: 4

SALES

Though Thanos does not have Darkseid’s level of presence in comics and animation, with fewer comic appearances than Darkseid overall.

At the same time, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has made the villain a pop icon. Together, Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame have brought in about $4.8 billion worldwide.

Likely, this is more than the revenue of all the movies in the DCEU combined.

ADVANTAGE: THANOS

ORIGIN STORY

In some respects, Darkseid’s origin story has been changed over DC continuity.

Post-Crisis, he was Prince Uxas who killed his brother Drax and claimed the Omega Effect. In the New 52, Darkseid was a peasant who ascended to the throne of Apokolips.

For the most part, the New God’s story deserved to be more known.

ORIGIN STORY

Really, Thanos’ origin story is better known. In true Marvel fashion, he is given a character flaw.

Namely, being a Deviant among the perfect Eternals of Titan. For the most part, this explains his descent into villainy. And his affection for the embodiment of Death.

Definitely, he is more fleshed out in his motivations.

 

DARKSEID’S FIRST APPEARANCE IS IN SUPERMAN’S PAL JIMMY OLSEN #134 CGC 8.0 FIRST APPEARANCE OF DARKSEID 1970 DC COMIC BOOK

THANOS’S FIRST APPEARANCE IS IN STAN LEE & JIM STARLIN SIGNED THE INVINCIBLE IRON MAN #55 REPRINT COMIC BAS SLAB

ADVANTAGE: THANOS

CHARACTER EVOLUTION

In many respects, both characters have evolved over the years. Namely, it took Darkseid millennia before finally obtaining the ALE.

In the New 52, Darkseid was conquering the DC multiverse, killing versions of Superman in order to find the ALE and Grail.

After Infinite Frontier, DC Comics revealed True Form Darkseid.

CHARACTER EVOLUTION

In addition, Thanos has evolved speedily. Once a third rate villain, he arose to prominence with the conquest of the Cosmic Cube.

Then, he set his sights on the Infinity Gauntlet. Post-IG, the Mad Titan attempted a path of redemption.

However, Thanos Wins revealed a possible future where the villain has eliminated all the heroes in the Marvel Universe.

ADVANTAGE: THANOS

 

ADVERTISE WITH US

INTERESTED IN DARKSEID AND THANOS? CLICK ON DC Vs Marvel : Showdown of the Century BELOW TO BUY THE PAPERBACK COMIC ON AMAZON.

CAST

Really, this is where Darkseid truly separates himself.

Indeed, as a New God and ruler of Apokolips, Darkseid has a colorful cast of characters.

From Desaad, to Granny Goodness, the Female Furies, and his immediate family like his uncle Steppenwolf.

During Jack Kirby’s Fourth World, the cast exemplified the type of cosmic opera that the New Gods can be.

CAST

Tragically, Thanos has remained a solitary figure. As a space conqueror, he has assembled the Black Order and conquered civilizations.

In Infinity, he comes to Earth looking for his Inhuman son Thane.

Despite his power, the Mad Titan has often had poor advisors that sought to dethrone him.

ADVANTAGE: DARKSEID

QUALITY OPPONENTS

For the most part, Darkseid has had God in Heaven or Abstracts in the Nil, namely the Monitors, as his quality opponents.

Though it occurred off-panel, Darkseid successfully waged war on Heaven and gained the Anti-Life Equation.

QUALITY OPPONENTS

Unfortunately, Marvel: The End is non-canon. At the same time, with the IG Thanos has successfully conquered the Marvel Universe.

ADVANTAGE: DARKSEID

VILLAINY

In this department, Darkseid figures as pure evil. First, with the Omega Effect he can erase and resurect life.

Second, with the ALE, he can erase free will. Finally, Darkseid constantly evolves into his True Form.

Let’s also add that Darkseid’s Desaad is an expert in torture and mind control.

VILLAINY

In reality, Thanos is psychotic.

Indeed, his lust for power has plagued him with a hubris that ultimately convinces him to be unfit for ultimate power.

In the end, we are assured Than conquers the Marvel Universe. But, Thanos seeks to be a God whereas Darkseid is a God.

ADVANTAGE: DARKSEID

 

VISITEZ NOTRE BOUTIQUE POUR LES BD!

 

POWER

See our Formidability rating in the previous article.

POWER

See our Formidability rating in the previous article.

ADVANTAGE: DARKSEID

POPULARITY

Generally, Darkseid is more popular in the comic medium. In the Post-Crisis continuity, he boasts 456 Appearances.

However, Google Search Results yield 4,340,000 results.

POPULARITY

In order for Thanos to match his popularity, we must add the Disciple of Death’s 362 Appearances to his 139 Minor Appearances.

As the winner, Google Search Results yield  46,700,000 results.

ADVANTAGE: THANOS

VERDICT:

Though Thanos is more popular and successful in sales, Darkseid is a classic villain who seeks to re-fashion the DC multiverse in his image. Tie.

And that’s our ranking! Don’t forget to leave comments if you liked the DC vs Marvel.


ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE

In 'Batman' (2002) #608, Batman faces the beastly villain Killer Croc.

Reviews: 00s Batman Graphic Novels Ranked From Best To Worst

 

  SUPPORT MY PATREON SUBSCRIBE TO RECEIVE NEWS AND UPDATES ABOUT THE BATTLE RANKER COMPETITION […]

The Classic JLA line-up radially to center: Batman, Aquaman, Martian Manhunter, Green Lantern, Flash, Superman, Wonder Woman.

Super Power Explained: The Classic JLA Big Seven Ranked In Formidability

 

 SUPER POWER IN TEAMS, SQUADS AND LEAGUES THE JLA ARE DC’S PREMIERE SUPERHERO TEAM The […]

In 'JLA' (1997) #3, Flash remembers the Flash fact to use the infinite mass punch against Zum.

Feat: Flash, ‘JLA’ #3

 

In ‘JLA’ (1997) #3, Flash uses the infinite mass punch against Zum, a White Martian. Let’s look at the super-strength feat.

In "Supreme" (2017) Matt Murdock changes from defense to prosecution.

Under-Appreciated Heroes/Villains: In The Debate Over Daredevil’s Guilty Plea, #WeStandWithDaredevil

 

 UNDER-APPRECIATED HEROES/VILLAINS In ‘Daredevil’ (2021) #28, Daredevil feels guilty for prosecuting Neil Rivate in prison. […]

In 'Fantastic Four Unlimited' (1993) #3, Invisible Woman creates a force field inside a black hole in the Negative Zone.

Super Power: 5 Super Powers That Make Invisible Woman Fantastic

 

 SUPER POWER IN POWER LEVEL INVISIBLE WOMAN’S FORCE FIELDS CAN SURVIVE A BLACK HOLE In […]

Overpowered Beings: An Alpha Male Amped, Blue Marvel Is The #BlackSuperman Rooting Out Racism

 

 OVERPOWERED BEINGS IN XENOPHOBIA ADAM BRASHEAR IS AN ALPHA MALE In Ultimates (2016) #4, Adam […]


LINKS

2009 Comic Book Sales to Comics Shops in Comichron.
Justice League Dark: Apokolips War (2020) in The Numbers.
Top Lifetime Grosses in Box Office Mojo.

ARE YOU A NEW OR RETURNING VISITOR? WRITE A REVIEW.

5 thoughts on “DC vs Marvel: Darkseid or Thanos, Who Is The Better Villain? (And First Appearance)

  1. […] of speech. Indeed, it is verbose, long and cryptic. Particularly, this applies to Skeletor and Darkseid. For the most part, the dialogue serves to move the story forward. Though it also serves as […]

  2. […] February, we compared both characters to find out who is the better villain. Now, this month, we compare two other A-list villains at DC and Marvel to find out who is the […]

  3. […] vote over Crisis on Infinite Earths Anti-Monitor, Annihilation Silver Surfer and the Watcher, Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet proved to be the Invincible […]

  4. […] Justice League vs Legion of Super-Heroes mini-series debuted. From Infinite Frontier, it continues Darkseid‘s quest for The Great Darkness. Moreover, an homage to the classic Legion story arc called […]

  5. […] Donny Cates and artist Geoff Shaw collaborate on the crossover. Really, the writing shines on Thanos’ villainy. Indeed, the art in the book is characteristic of Marvel Legacy: layered, detailed and colorful. […]

Leave a Reply