Posted on Leave a comment

DC vs Marvel: Lex Luthor vs Doctor Doom, Who Is The Better Villain? (Comics, TV and Film)

 

*Our website can officially be translated in 10 different languages.
*Look for the dropdown menu on the right sidebar with English and the British flag.
*On mobile, scroll to the footer section of the page.

DC VS MARVEL

DEATH BATTLE!

IN SUPERVILLAINS

THE SMARTEST HUMANS AT DC AND MARVEL

*Let’s commemorate the 82nd anniversary of Lex Luthor’s first appearance.

In January, we ranked the formidabilities in a potential Darkseid vs Thanos battle. And we looked at the characters in continuity at their highest powers: Thanos with the Infinity Gauntlet and Darkseid with the Anti-Life Equation.

In February, we compared both characters to find out who is the better villain. Now, this month, we compare two other A-list villains at DC and Marvel to find out who is the better villain.

At DC and Marvel, Lex Luthor and Doctor Doom are definitely the two smartest humans in their respective universes. For his part, Lex Luthor has planned world domination while Doctor Doom has conquered the power of God on multiple occasions.

To this end, we have come up with a villainy score that compares both characters in eight categories: Sales, Origin Story, Character Evolution, Cast, Quality Opponents, Villainy, Power, Popularity. Before we compare our villains let’s list some rules.

  1. The Villainy Score is rated out of 8 points.
  2. For Doctor Doom, we list only the Earth-616 continuity and for Lex Luthor Post-Crisis, Post-Flashpoint and Rebirth.
  3. Since we are comparing Sales and Popularity, we include the villains’ performance in other media and their Google Search Results.
  4. For Power, we list their highest achievements across Earth-616, Post-Crisis, Post-Flashpoint and Rebirth continuities.

So, let’s compare Lex Luthor and Doctor Doom in the villainy department.

 

VILLAINY SCORES

Lex Luthor. DC Comics.

VILLAINY SCORE: 5

SALES

For sales, Lex Luthor outperforms Doctor Doom. In the comic medium, it appears the Metropolis businessman lags behind the Baron of Iron.

In 2005, Lex Luthor: The Man of Steel #1 ranked 38 in unit sales on the Top Comics of March 2005. At the same time, Lex Luthor performs very well as POTUS in Our Worlds at War whose first issue ranked 19th in unit sales and sold 59157 issues on the Top Comics of July 2001.

In animation, Superman: The Animated Series and Justice League Unlimited have created the best portrayals of Lex Luthor. And to this day, Michael Rosenbaum remains the most celebrated version of Lex Luthor with Smallville. And the Total Estimated Domestic Video Sales for the series is $151,375,254.

In the movie department, the controversial Batman v Superman movie still gave us a more significant live-action adaptation than Doctor Doom in Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer. Overall, BvS earned $855 million internationally.

Doctor Doom. Marvel Comics.

VILLAINY SCORE: 3

SALES

Though Doctor Doom stars in more event comics with prominent roles, he performs less than his counterpart in the different media.

In 1984, Marvel Super Heroes Secret Wars ranked as Marvel’s first company-wide crossover event and the top-selling comic year-long with 250000 copies sold. In 2015, Doctor Doom becomes God-doom in Secret Wars whose first issue ranked 1st in unit sales with 527618 sold on the Top Comics of May 2015.

With animation, the Spider-Man: The Animated Series and The Avengers: Earth’s Mightiest Heroes have created the best portrayals of Doom. However, very few portrayals have had the lasting impact that his counterpart has had.

In the movie department, the controversial live-action adaptation of Doctor Doom in Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer was not successful. Overall, FF earned $289,480,691 internationally.

ADVANTAGE: LEX LUTHOR

ORIGIN STORY

In some respects, Lex Luthor’s origin story deserves to be well known.

Post-Crisis, he was a billionaire mogul in Metropolis who was self-made. At a young age, he overcame his parents’ abuse, to dominate the streets of the Suicide Slums. With his commanding leadership skills and his genius, Lex founded Lexcorp. Over time, his evil nature won him the enmity of Superman, his nemesis.

In his first appearance, Alexei Luthor was a mad scientist who took over small European nations before World War II.

LEX LUTHOR’S FIRST APPEARANCE IN ACTION COMICS (1940) #23 IS COLLECTED IN SUPERMAN: THE GOLDEN AGE OMNIBUS VOL. 1

ORIGIN STORY

Really, Doom’s origin story is better known. In true Marvel fashion, he is given a character flaw.

Namely, Victor Von Doom was the child of gypsies. Orphaned at a young age, his mother died when she attempted a deal with the demon Mephisto. In order to free his mother from hell, Victor became Doctor Doom. With his evil genius, he united science and magic. Over time, his evil nature won him the enmity of the Fantastic Four, his nemeses.

In his first appearance, Doctor Doom kidnapped Sue Storm.

DOCTOR DOOM’S FIRST APPEARANCE IN FANTASTIC FOUR (1962) #5 IS COLLECTED IN ESSENTIAL FANTASTIC FOUR, VOL. 1 (MARVEL ESSENTIALS)

ADVANTAGE: DOCTOR DOOM

CHARACTER EVOLUTION

In many respects, Lex Luthor is definitely one of the most interesting character at DC Comics.

Post-Crisis, his motivations have centered on either destroying Superman’s reputation or besting him through his lackeys. What makes Lex Luthor work is that he genuinely believes himself to be humanity’s savior by virtue of his superior intelligence.

During Dark Nights: Death Metal, Lex may have finally become good. In fact, he proved why he is the smartest human in the DC multiverse by creating the weapon in the World Forge that created Truth Incarnate Wonder Woman.

CHARACTER EVOLUTION

In addition, Doctor Doom has shown he is Marvel’s Greatest Villain. Really, during the first Secret Wars, he stole Beyonder’s power becoming the Supreme Being of the Universe.

Similarly, Doom believes himself to be humanity’s savior. In Doomwar, he has beheld a potential future where he is Earth’s ruler.

However, like other Marvel villains, Doctor Doom ultimately knows he is not fit for ultimate power. Hence, his flaw proves his undoing in the end.

ADVANTAGE: LEX LUTHOR

VISIT THE BATTLES OF THE WEEK

INTERESTED IN DC COMICS OR MARVEL COMICS? CLICK ON The DC Comics Encyclopedia: The Definitive Guide to the Characters of the DC Universe AND Ultimate Marvel Encyclopedia Vol. 1 by Mark D. Beazley, Jeff Youngquist Matt Brady (2003-05-03) BELOW TO BUY THE hARDCOVER COMICS ON AMAZON.

*Read our product review.

CAST

Really, this is where Lex Luthor truly separates himself.

Indeed, as a businessman and the smartest man on DC Earth, Lex Luthor has proven a better leader. In fact, he showed how an A-list supervillain can legally become the President of the United States.

From Lexcorp, to the Injustice Gang, to the United States, even Darkseid and Perpetua, Lex Luthor is an expert at making deals.

During Our Worlds At War, he won even Superman to his cause in order to stop Imperiex.

CAST

Tragically, Doctor Doom has remained a conflicted figure. As a conqueror and world leader, he leads the sovereign nation of Latveria.

Incredibly, Doom commands a religious following and his people actually love him.

In addition, he has sought companionship often in treacherous ways though he has remained single-minded. Effortlessly, Doom could conquer the world, however, it would take manipulation and deception.

During Avengers: Emperor Doom, Doctor Doom realizes that world conquest is an illusion.

ADVANTAGE: LEX LUTHOR

QUALITY OPPONENTS

For the most part, Luthor is at a disadvantage. Indeed, most of his opponents are Cosmic Beings.

At the same time, Justice League: Darkseid War showed Lex Luthor can take on Gods or Abstracts.

QUALITY OPPONENTS

For the most part, Doctor Doom more or less ties Lex Luthor in this department.

Secret Wars showed that Doom’s Quality Opponents are properly Gods or Abstracts. In fact, Beyonder may be the God of the Marvel multiverse.

ADVANTAGE: TIE

VILLAINY

In this department, Lex Luthor may have foreshadowed the greatest evil. However, his humanity shows he can be redeemed.

With the Worlogog, Lex Luthor created an alternate future where Darkseid imposed the Anti-Life Equation on DC Earth. In a sense, this may have contributed to Final Crisis.

In Dark Nights Metal, Luthor joined forces with Perpetua who re-made the multiverse in her image. However, he redeemed himself by supplying the weapon for Truth Incarnate Wonder Woman’s victory.

VILLAINY

In this department, Doctor Doom is pure evil. In fact, he cannot be redeemed. Indeed, his faith in magic is only a masquerade for his lust for power.

In Doomwar, Doom used the purple Man to possess the will of all humans on Earth. On mutiple occasions, his lust for power caused him to steal the power of the Silver Surfer, the Watcher and Galactus.

In Secret Wars, GodDoom rules Battleworld having stolen the Beyonders’ powers. Even here, Doom’s inner darkness makes him a powerful villain.

ADVANTAGE: DOCTOR DOOM

POWER

With his Universal-Level Strength Class, Lex Luthor with the Omega Effect in Darkseid War has a score of 71.5. Though his lack of Teamwork with the JLA limits his potential. His Formidability rating is Metahuman.

To note, Lex Luthor with the Omega Effect is less powerful than Darkseid with the ALE. Which explains how he could not defeat Anti-Monitor. In fact, it takes the ALE to stand a chance though AM is at least as powerful as Darkseid with ALE.

SCORE: 71.5

FORMIDABILITY: METAHUMAN

Strength Class: Universal 84%
Weaknesses: None 100%
Quality Opponents: God or Abstract 100%
Limitations: Teamwork 67%

POWER

Though God-Doom in Secret Wars is Nigh-omnipotent in Strength Class, his Hubris and Power Dependency on Molecule Man, give him a score of 71. His Formidability rating is Metahuman.

To note, God-Doom is about as formidable as Thanos with the IG. Which explains how Black Panther was able to go toe to toe with him in Secret Wars (2016) #9. Though Doctor Doom was likely toying with him.

SCORE: 71

FORMIDABILITY: METAHUMAN

Strength Class: Nigh-Omnipotence 100%
Weaknesses: Hubris 50%
Quality Opponents: God or Abstract 100%
Limitations: Power Dependency 92%

ADVANTAGE: LEX LUTHOR

 

POPULARITY

Generally, Lex Luthor is more popular in the comic medium. In the Post-Crisis continuity alone, he boasts 789 Appearances.

However, Google Search Results yield 12,500,000 results.

POPULARITY

In order for Doctor Doom to match his popularity, we must add the Baron of Iron’s 841 Appearances to his 218 Minor Appearances.

As the winner, Google Search Results yield  98,100,000 results.

ADVANTAGE: DOCTOR DOOM

VERDICT:

Though Doctor Doom operates on a higher scale, Lex Luthor proves to be equally intelligent and a far more human villain.

Lex Luthor wins.

And that’s our ranking!

IF YOU LIKED THE DC VS MARVEL, PLEASE RATE THE ARTICLE OR SHARE WITH FRIENDS AND FOLLOWERS.


ARTICLES YOU MIGHT LIKE

  • Marvel Day: Doctor Doom Sets The Trap And Steals The Silver Surfer’s Power Cosmic

    In 'Fantastic Four #57' (1968), Doctor Doom uses high intensity inductors to steal the Silver Surfer's Power Cosmic.

    In ‘Fantastic Four’ (1968) #57, Doctor Doom Steals The Silver Surfer’s Power Cosmic. What’s his master plan?


  • DC Day: Static, Your Neighborhood Black Superhero’s Crackling First Appearance In The New 52

    In 'Static Shock' (2011) #1, Static Shock appears on the streets of New York.

    In ‘Static Shock’ (2011) #1, is the first appearance of Static in the New 52. Who is Static?


  • The Mightiest Punch! In The Modern Age Of Comics: Ranking

     RESULTS FROM TWITTER POLLS: How we weighed The Mightiest Punch! In The Modern Age Of Comics. The weight was calculated from statements of power and from the super feat! Because the punches displayed were at a minimum, Building Level (more on that later), we weighed The Mightiest Punch! based on the weight the super feat […]


  • Feat: Luke Cage, ‘Power Man #17’

    Power Man punches through a brick wall facing gunfire, "the first and still the greatest black superhero of all!"

    Today! We rank a Super Strength feat from… Power Man!


  • “52 #45” Review

     PRODUCT REVIEWS In ’52’ (2007) #45, Black Adam massacres every man, woman and child in Bialya grieved over Isis’s death caused by the Third Horseman. Photo/DC Comics IN READING GUIDES, LISTS, REVIEWS One of the most disastrous events in comic book history. Gift this graphic novel to your friends and collectors on the occasions of […]


  • “Action Comics (1938-2011) #831” Review

     PRODUCT REVIEWS IN READING GUIDES, LISTS, REVIEWS One of the marquee showdowns in comic book history. Collect this comic on the occasions of social clubs and board games. Available on Amazon. Click on the Amazon product image below to purchase the comic. PRODUCT DESCRIPTION A VILLAINS UNITED tie-in! Get ready for Superman vs. Black Adam–and […]


  • “Alan Moore’s: Supreme: The Return” Review

    In 'Supreme: The Return' (1999), Supreme buries Shadow Supreme in the center of the Earth.

     PRODUCT REVIEWS In Supreme: The Return (1999), Supreme buries Shadow Supreme in the center of the Earth. Image Comics. IN READING GUIDES, LISTS, REVIEWS One of the most extreme Supreme stories. Gift this comic to your friends and comic collectors on the occasions of Comic-Cons and festivals. Available on Amazon. Click on the Amazon product […]


  • “Amazing Spider-Man (1963-1998) Annual #3” Review

     PRODUCT REVIEWS IN READING GUIDES, LISTS, REVIEWS Truly, one of the greatest Spider-Man classics in comic book history. Gift this graphic novel to your friends and collectors on the occasions of trips to Comic-Cons and festivals. Available on Amazon. Click on the Amazon product image below to purchase the Kindle & Comixology comic. PRODUCT DESCRIPTION […]



REFERENCES

March 2005 Comic Book Sales to Comics Shops in Comichron.
July 2001 Comic Book Sales to Comics Shops in Comichron.
Smallville (2001) in The Numbers.
Box Office: ‘Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice’ Was A $855M Wash in Forbes.
1984 Comic Book Sales to Comics Shops in Comichron.
May 2015 Comic Book Sales to Comics Shops in Comichron.
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007) in The Numbers.
Secret Wars Vol 1 9 in Marvel Database.

Leave a Reply